![]() |
| Veena Akama-Makia (Clare) & Jacquelyn Stucker (Gwen) © RBO/Marc Brenner |
Naomi Woo (Conductor)
![]() |
| 4.48 Psychosis © RBO/Marc Brenner |
![]() |
| Sophia Burgos (Suzy) & Jacquelyn Stucker (Gwen) © RBO/Marc Brenner |
Reflections on classical music, recordings and performances
![]() |
| Veena Akama-Makia (Clare) & Jacquelyn Stucker (Gwen) © RBO/Marc Brenner |
![]() |
| 4.48 Psychosis © RBO/Marc Brenner |
![]() |
| Sophia Burgos (Suzy) & Jacquelyn Stucker (Gwen) © RBO/Marc Brenner |
![]() |
| Lluís Calvet i Pey (Figaro) © Glyndebourne Productions ltd. Photo: Craig Fuller |
![]() |
| Nico Darmanin (Count Almaviva) & Hongni Wu (Rosina) © Glyndebourne Productions ltd. Photo: Craig Fuller |
![]() |
| Fabio Capitanucci (Dr Bartolo) & Lluís Calvet i Pey (Figaro) © Glyndebourne Productions ltd. Photo: Craig Fuller |
![]() |
| Cumhur Görgün (Basilio), Nico Darmanin (Count Almaviva) & Hongni Wu (Rosina) © Glyndebourne Productions ltd. Photo: Craig Fuller |
★★★★
After a strong opening to their new season just a few weeks ago, the Brighton Philharmonic Orchestra’s pared down wind and brass forces could have seemed like an anticlimax after the excitement of Rachmaninov, and the augmented brass forces required for Janáček’s glorious Sinfonietta (see my review here). But not at all – a first half of spiky, jazzy Stravinsky followed by Mozart’s sublime ‘Gran Partita’ Serenade was the perfect programme to show off the talents of the BPO wind and brass sections (with timpani and double basses added to the mix).
Stravinsky’s brief Symphonies of Wind Instruments gets occasional outings on the concert platform as an interesting opener (as here), but the real treat was his Concerto for Piano and Wind Instruments, much more rarely heard. I’m not sure why, other than the unusual orchestral forces, but here it fit the programme perfectly.
Stravinsky dedicated his Symphonies of Wind Instruments to the memory of Debussy, who had died two years before. A chorale was his starting point, which actually comes at the end of the piece, with sections of austere ‘litanies’ leading up to it. The writing is spiky and edgy, and whilst the notes were there (mostly – there were one or two stray entries in the sequences of tutti chords), MacGregor and the BPO players didn’t quite manage to make the piece fly today. Nevertheless, the winding flute solo, joined by the clarinet weaving in and out of the line, and the darkly brooding brass in the chorale were high points here.
![]() |
| Joanna MacGregor and members of the BPO © Nick Boston |
![]() |
| Khrystyna Mykhailichenko & the Brighton Philharmonic Orchestra © Frances Marshall |
![]() |
| Joanna MacGregor © Frances Marshall |
Gershwin’s lively Cuban Overture opened proceedings, with its quartet of Cuban percussion instruments at the side of the stage behind the violins, with more percussion at the back. It took the orchestra a little while to settle into the rhythms, but once up and running, they had fun with it. There’s a lot going on, not just the percussion quartet, but frequent cross rhythms for the woodwinds, as well as solo moments for cor anglais, a slinky clarinet, and a duet for oboe and cor anglais. Given the busyness, balance wasn’t always ideal, so some detail was obscured, but all in all, this was a joyful opener, the Tom and Jerry style strings and the brassy buildup back to the opening music bringing it all to a playful conclusion, all steered with a bounce from MacGregor.
Ukrainian-born pianist Khrystyna Mykhailichenko, pupil of MacGregor’s, then gave a confident and exciting rendition of Rachmaninov’s Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini, all the more impressive as it was her first live performance of the work. She rippled effortlessly through the rapid motion of the faster variations, yet was sensitive and expressive in the big romantic D flat variation. The orchestral support was on the whole sound, although there were moments of less than unanimous tuning amongst the reeds and horns – all in all, woodwind blend could have been better. The strings produced a rich sound, however, and their response to the big romantic tune was suitably warm, and the woodwinds’ pickup after Mykhailichenko’s thundering double octaves was solid. MacGregor was alert to both soloist and orchestra throughout, making for a strong performance here. Given the connection, here’s hoping Mykhailichenko returns to Brighton soon.
![]() |
| Emily Trubshaw and the BPO strings © Frances Marshall |
And finally, the Janáček. His Sinfonietta was written for the Sokol Festival in Prague, promoting Czech culture and sport, and it is packed full of fairytale and folk influences, as well as the blazing fanfare that opens and closes the work. The brass reinforcements arrived on stage and stood for their glorious fanfare, no fewer than nine trumpets and two bass trumpets, delivering the striking opening with precision and confidence. We were then given rattling woodwinds, muted trombones and dancing strings in The Castle, followed by rich, sliding strings in The Queen’s Monastery, this movement concluding with virtuosic horn whinnies. The Street Leading to the Castle is dominated by another brassy theme (for those of a certain age forever linked to Crown Court), and this was again delivered with energy, with winding violins, raspy muted horns and bells. The Town Hall, Brno creates a dazzling townscape, and all the dancing and activity built up to the brass standing once again for the return of their fanfare, their majestic confidence bringing this successful season opener to a blazing conclusion.
![]() |
| I Fagiolini and the English Cornett and Sackbut Ensemble © Monika S Jakubowska (2023) |
![]() |
| I Fagiolini & the English Cornett & Sackbut Ensemble © Nick Boston |
I very much enjoyed the Phoenix Consort’s debut recording back in 2024 (review here), and they’re back on Convivium Records with their third recording, Choral Contemplation, an album of sacred introits and motets by a range of contemporary composers. Adam Whitmore founded the Phoenix Consort during the pandemic at Durham University, since then expanding to draw on young choral artists from across the UK. In their short time together, they have already won a couple of competition prizes and toured in northern Spain, and once again I am struck by their strong command of blend and tone.
This new disc has close connections with their record company too. Adrian Green (b.1985), Convivium’s Managing Director, is also a composer himself, and the connecting thread between all the composers on this disc is the influence of the self-taught polymath and teacher, Leon MacLaren (1910-1994), who set up the Music Group at the School of Philosophy and Economic Science (which he also founded). That Music Group looked at the nature of sound and silence, and the connection between music and the meaning of text – in his words, what matters is ‘not what the words say, but where they’re coming from, and music has the capacity to connect us with this’. As someone who has sung chorally all my life, inevitably singing many settings of sacred texts, despite not having any religious belief, I do find this interesting, as I know from personal experience the power of music to move and touch one’s ‘soul’ on a deep level, regardless of one’s beliefs.
With 19 works from 9 composers (just one woman amongst them), most coming in at around two minutes long, it’s not possible to comment on every piece. Suffice to say the standard is consistently high, with clarity of text-setting in common across the board. This clarity is enhanced throughout by the crystal precision of the Phoenix Consort, with a purity of tone that nevertheless gives expressive weight when needed, thus avoiding the somewhat anodyne purity that can characterise even the best of choirs. Harmonically there are few shocks here, with many pieces centring strongly around a fixed tonic, and minimal modulation. Yet the settings are mostly effective and seldom lacking in interest.
Picking out a few highlights, David Fletcher’s (1931-2024) Set me as a seal contrasts weaving lines with sections of closer homophony, and O Oriens by David Goymour (b.1946) is one of the more polyphonic offerings, in contrast with John-Paul Bowman’s (b.1985) homophonic, simply set A new commandment, which follows it. Noel Skinner’s (1947-2019) For the Fallen is a touchingly contemplative setting of Binyon’s familiar poem, here arranged for SATB from Skinner’s original for young voices by Matthew Coleridge. Rosemary Broadbent’s (b.1950) And he arose combines tenderness in its outer sections with a more playfully dancing central section. Gillian Thompson joins on piano to accompany the singers for Peter Blumson’s (1942-2026) What is man?, which combines its straightforward melody with the steady motion of the piano to simple effect.
Green’s The Absorbeat (Prayer of St Francis), the longest, and most striking piece here, contrasts sections for upper or lower voices with pulsing harmonies below a soaring soprano line. Falling sequences of suspensions, richly sung by the Phoenix Consort lower voices in particular, increase in intensity, adding urgency to the prayerful pleas. Derek Saunders’ (b.1966) Be still, and know that I am God uses drones, mostly in the lower voices, to underpin the gently moving parts, creating a successful sense of stillness. Skinner’s The earth is the Lord’s is for upper voices, which shine brightly here. Baritone Will Pate impresses in Green’s Every good gift, his Latin chant initially alone then set against effective choral writing, and the choir further excel in Bruce Ramell’s (b.1939) declamatory O Adonai which follows this.
Strong solos from within the choir enhance a few pieces, adding further interest to an otherwise relatively homogenous soundworld, perhaps inevitable in such an extensive collection of short sacred settings. Of course ‘contemplation’ is in the disc’s title, but greater rhythmic variety and energy would have been welcome to break things up a little. Nonetheless, this is an impressive collection of works that choirs looking for new repertoire would do well to explore (with free downloadable scores here). And I look forward to hearing more from Adam Whitmore’s Phoenix Consort.
![]() |
| Kirill Petrenko conducts the Berliner Philharmoniker © Berliner Philharmoniker/Lena Laine |
![]() |
| Kirill Petrenko conducts the Berliner Philharmoniker © Berliner Philharmoniker/Lena Laine |