![]() |
Alex Otterburn (James) & Heidi Stober (Mary) © Ellie Kurttz |
![]() |
Mary, Queen of Scots, cast © Ellie Kurttz |
![]() |
Thea Musgrave © Nick Boston |
Read my full review on Bachtrack here.
Reflections on classical music, recordings and performances
![]() |
Alex Otterburn (James) & Heidi Stober (Mary) © Ellie Kurttz |
![]() |
Mary, Queen of Scots, cast © Ellie Kurttz |
![]() |
Thea Musgrave © Nick Boston |
Pianist Barry Douglas’ seventh volume of Schubert’s Solo Piano Works came out in November, and this continues to be a highly noteworthy survey. He’s been taking his time – the first volume was released in 2014. This does allow us (and presumably Douglas) to focus more on the current volume’s works in isolation, rather than trying to assess the recordings en masse. Previous volumes have shown Douglas’ approach to be weightier than some, emphasising the forward-looking Romanticism in Schubert’s works, rather than lighter, Classical elements. But that’s a generalisation of course – Douglas can be delicate too, as in the gentle opening to the Sonata in E flat major, D568, and in that opening movement’s subsiding coda. But in between, there is bounce and pace, yet the throbbing chords in the development are never too weighty, everything kept in proportion. Similarly, the slow movement builds from its simple, plaintive opening, with weight and passion growing, yet never overly dramatic. Douglas gives a stop-start kick to the Minuet, with jaunty dotted rhythms in the Trio. That sense of dance is carried forward into the finale, where Schubert’s flow of ideas is at its most inventive, and Douglas certainly conveys that sense of effortless outpouring of material. In the Sonata in G major, D894, Douglas’ full-on approach comes more to the fore, with heft and dramatically crashing chords in the mammoth opening movement. Throughout this movement, there is a constant contrast between those fiery chords and a kind of lilting dance, and Douglas emphasises the extremes of this contrast. This element of contrast continues into the second movement, with a gently lyrical slow waltz followed by a weightier, dramatic second section, with more crashes from the extremes of the keyboard. There’s more drama in the Minuet, with forward drive from Douglas in the grace notes, yet the folksy Trio is given a much lighter touch. The chattering repeated notes of the finale demonstrate Douglas’ deft articulation, and his virtuosity keeps things dancing along with fluid, rippling runs and feisty pacing. Douglas ends the disc, as in other volumes thus far, with two transcriptions by Liszt of Schubert songs. Gretchen am Spinnrade has beautifully relentless spinning rhythms against the increasingly intense melodic line of the song, which Douglas brings out with striking lyricism, the intertwined elements of Liszt’s transcription adding to the song’s claustrophobic drama. In Wohin?, from Die schone Mullerin, the rippling ‘accompaniment’ is less frenzied, and the song can soar above more easily, even as Liszt’s virtuosic demands increase. Douglas’ command here is highly impressive, bringing to a close another strong volume in this collection.
![]() |
Jordi Savall & Hespèrion XXI © The Wigmore Hall Trust |
![]() |
Jordi Savall © The Wigmore Hall Trust |
Robert Parsons (c.1535-1571): The song called trumpets a6
Pierre Attaingnant (1494-1552): Pavane de la Guerre
Orlando Gibbons (1583-1625): In Nomine a5 No. 1 (pub. c.1610)
John Dowland (1563-1626): Semper Dowland semper dolens (pub. 1604)
The King of Denmark's Galliard (pub. 1605)
Giovanni Maria Trabaci (c.1575-1647): Toccata di Durezze et Ligature
Gioseffo Guami (1542-1611): Canzon a4 sopra 'La Battaglia'
Clement Woodcock (c.1540-1590): Browning my dear
Antony Holborne (1545-1602): Galliard No. 24
John Ward (c.1589-1638): Fantasia No. 4
Anon.: Pavane de la petite Guerre & Gaillarde
Bourrée d’Avignonez
William Brade (1560-1630): Turkische Intrada
Alfonso Ferrabosco (1543-1588): Four-note pavan
William Brade: Galliard a6
John Jenkins (1592-1678): The Bell Pavan
Sebastián Aguilera de Heredia (1561-1627): Tiento de batalla
Samuel Scheidt (1587-1654): Galliard Battaglia
William Lawes (1602-1645): Paven from Consort Sett a5 in C
Robert Johnson (c.1583-1633) & William Brade: The King's Morisco
Henry Purcell (1659-1695): Fantasia upon one note in F Z745 (c.1680)
Johann Sebastian Bach (1685-1750): Contrapunctus 9 from the Art of Fugue BWV1080 (by 1742, rev. 1745-9)
Juan Bautista José Cabanilles (c.1644-1712): Obertura - Corrente Italiana
Encores:
Anon.: Tonada del Chimo, from Codex Martínez Compañón
Anon.: Scottish Dance.
![]() |
Jordi Savall & Hespèrion XXI © Nick Boston |
'Savall and friends delivered every gem with assured and effortless precision, letting slip an occasional sense of their enjoyment in their craft at the more boisterous moments'.
'... the Oberture e Corrente Italian by Cabanilles... the drums announced the majestic opening, then there was a deft switch from theorbo to guitar for the livelier rhythms of the Corrente, with tambourine and cascading viol lines dancing to the very end'.
Jordi Savall
© Nick Boston
'Rocking theorbo rhythms and joyous dance energy from the players was topped with virtuosic riffing from Savall'.
'The velvet viol sounds, the spirited percussion, the subtle theorbo or strumming guitar, with occasional virtuosic bursts of ornamented energy proved that this music is their joy, and it was a privilege to witness it. Happy 50th birthday, Hespèrion XXI!'
Read my full review on Bachtrack here.
Sam Barton (conductor)
Antonia Hyatt (conductor)
Gaynor Gallant (piano, oboe)
Francesca Urquhart (double bass)
Tom Hyatt (percussion)
7.30pm, Saturday 14 December 2024
St Luke's Church, Brighton
★★★★
It’s always great to see what interesting repertoire that ‘genre fluid’ Resound Voices and their partners in crime, the Rebelles will come up with. But this time, for Twistmas’, they excelled themselves, with a highly eclectic mix of works from all kinds of genres. With classical, folk, musical theatre and popular music on the menu, pretty much all bases were covered. Resound Voices, a lower voice ensemble, was founded in 2011 by Stefan Holmstrom, and is now conducted by Sam Barton, and the Rebelles, a women’s ensemble is conducted by Antonia Hyatt. And speaking of menu, their ‘theme’ for the evening was to structure their programme around a feast, with amuse-bouche and appetisers leading to a main course, dessert and a final digestif encore.
So Resound Voices gave us the amuse-bouche course, with a mostly Nordic flavour. Söderberg’s arrangement of the traditional Swedish herding song, Limu Limu Lima began with a strong, smooth baritone line, and the harmonies once established were precisely tuned. American composer Rosephanye Powell’s Non Nobis, Domine contrasted well with its bouncing rhythms and crossing musical ideas, and here we heard the men’s full warm tutti sound for the first time, with a strong, bright final chord. Back to Sweden next, with Gustaf Nordqvist’s popular Christmas song, Jul, Jul, Strålande, Jul. This gave the guys the opportunity to show off one of their major strengths, their gloriously bright high first tenors, and the overall sound here was beautifully sweet, with faultless tuning. Then to the Disney film Frozen, but no, not that song – instead, the Sámi song, Vuelie (the South Sámi word for ‘yoik’, the chanting style of their traditional songs). Once again, the high tenors shone here, and conductor Sam Barton shaped a strong dynamic range here too. They ended their section with a tricky arrangement of Pure Imagination (from the original Willy Wonka film), not quite nailing every complex harmony here, but delivering the song’s sentiment with commitment.
Then it was the turn of the Rebelles to give us the appetisers. They began with conductor Antonia Hyatt’s own arrangement of The Movie In My Mind, a darkly moving song from Miss Saigon. The women delivered this with passion, and immediately demonstrated their ability to tell a story, with a particularly strong solo part standing out. An arrangement of Jane Siberry’s The Valley followed, with a rich contralto sound on display, although a few of the middle harmonies were a little unclear here. Noël Nouvelet followed, with drum and double bass joining. The French text was clearly a bit of a challenge here, with more reliance on their copies than usual, but it was a nonetheless striking performance, upping the energy levels of the evening. A lively if slightly frenetic performance of Bach’s Suscepit Israel from the Magnificat followed, with oboe, piano and bass accompaniment. They finished their set with David Guetta’s When Love Takes Over, a great upbeat number, with the combined voices carrying well over the full band accompaniment here.
The evening’s first half finished with the two groups joining, firstly for a lovely arrangement of Gabriel’s Message, and it was great to hear their full combined choral harmonies for the first time. They then finished with a crazy Alleluia by Jake Runestad, with whole tone scales, constantly changing time signatures and wild energy, all held together expertly by Barton’s clear conducting.
The second half opened with a comedic turn from three of the men, and a fun and cheeky number, Santa’s My Boyfriend, the guys hamming it up beautifully. Nicholas Ryan Kelly’s dark Christmas number, Cold Moon followed, complete with quotes from the Carol of the Bells. Here it was perhaps most noticeable that the guys, positioned a little further back on the steps than the women, were muted a little by the church’s acoustic – a more forward position would have better supported their sound. Once again in Sam Barton’s very tricky arrangement of Have Yourself A Merry Little Xmas, it was again the first tenors that shone, holding things together as the very complex harmonies shifted beneath them. Another dark number followed, the very intricate and clever Time, by J L Cook, with the guys managing well the rhythms as words are dropped from the text on each repetition. They ended their ‘main course’ with Children Go Where I Send Thee, in a version popular with US choruses, including the Boston Gay Men’s Chorus, giving it particular significance for first tenor James, who introduced it. They gave us their most energetic performance of the evening so far here, and nailed the building up of the clapping rhythms.
And onto dessert! The Rebelles began with a wonderfully sassy rendition of Gonna Wash That Man, with an especially strong solo line, and then contrasted it with The Lord is my Shepherd by Howard Goodall (yes, of The Vicar of Dibley fame). The solo here was bright and pure, with clear choral harmonies from the rest of the singers. Reger’s Mary’s Cradle Song had a warm full unison sound, with a suitably gentle lilt. Then they finished with more gospel, a confidently dramatic rendition of Music Down in My Soul, with powerful soprano and alto solos.
![]() |
Khatia Buniatishvili & the Academy of St Martin in the Fields © Nick Boston |